I got the same sort of impression as you about John T Reed too. He focuses heavily on the details which can be nice at times but he focused a lot on the negative aspects about what he was talking about.

I also feel the same way about Kiyosaki's overall advice. As I mentioned in my post there are some good pieces of advice that he provides. The issue comes when you take every piece of his advice and don't think critically about it which was the intention of this post to convey that idea.